Policing safer now than in previous decades despite recent officer deaths: Expert

After three police officers in Canada were killed over the past two weeks, a criminology expert says the number of on-duty cop fatalities this year remains within historical levels, with data showing that policing is generally safer now than in previous decades.

Montreal police officer Mohamed Lamine Benredouane, 34, was shot dead on Monday after responding to a 911 call about a shooter at a hotel in the city’s Côte-des-Neiges district. A civilian was also killed, as was the suspect. A second police officer was injured.

Read more:

That came after two officers in Ontario were killed two days apart earlier in the month.

Ontario Provincial Police Const. Tarun Bali, 29, was killed in Hearst, Ont., on June 9 while attempting to stop a fleeing vehicle. Toronto police Const. Marc Pinizzotto, 43, was fatally shot on June 11 while officers were carrying out a search during a raid linked to investigations into multiple shootings, including one at the U.S. Consulate in March. In each case, a suspect has been charged with first-degree murder.

Ontario Premier Doug Ford wrote to Prince Edward Island Premier Rob Lantz on Tuesday requesting an “emergency discussion” among Canada’s premiers at next month’s Council of the Federation meeting to address what he called an “alarming trend.”

“These tragedies underscore the need for a serious national conversation about public safety, support for law enforcement and the growing risks faced by those who put themselves in harm’s way every day,” Ford wrote to Lantz, who is the current chair of the council.

But Justin Piché, a criminology professor at the University of Ottawa, says the officers’ deaths in a short period do not necessarily point to a new trend.

Piché, who has collected and analyzed data on Canadian police deaths from the past 64 years, said current figures are within historical range, taking into account that the number of police officers has significantly increased since 1962.

“The number of deaths as well as the rate of deaths of on-duty police officers was much higher, generally speaking, in the 1960s, the 1970s, and early 1980s,” he said in a phone interview Tuesday.

According to a recent report by Piché, there were 416 on-duty police officer deaths across Canada during the study period, averaging about 6.5 deaths per year.

The deadliest years for police in the 64-year period were 1962 and 1968, which saw 16 on-duty officer deaths each, the report said. That was followed by the year 1964, which had 15 such deaths.

Piché noted that police officers are more likely to die in an accident than to be intentionally killed, with 58 per cent of total on-duty deaths stemming from accidents.

The report also noted that while there was a spike in 2023 after eight officers died on duty that year — six of them as a result of intentional violence — there were no on-duty police deaths in 2024 and 2025.

Car accidents are the leading cause of on duty police officer deaths in Canada, causing 160 of 416 total deaths. Intentional gunfire follows at 149 deaths, the report said.

“I think while policing carries a lot of symbolism, there are other groups of people in Canada who die for a living at higher rates than police officers,” he said, adding that industries including fishing, mining, forestry and construction generally have higher rates of workplace deaths when compared to policing.

“That’s not to minimize the deaths of anyone or any group of workers, but the fact of the matter is that policing, as far as dying for a living goes, is safer than working in a number of other industries.”

This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 24, 2026.